To Rick the Lone Wolf:
First off, I respect that you finished the trail, despite the difficulties you encountered while en route.
I’m sorry, tho, that you seem so intent on criticizing other hikers and what they’re choosing to do out there. (You did this a lot while hiking, too, but that’s another story).
The ATC Description/definition is just that—it isn’t a Guidebook, Manual, or Rule Book. There is no “Rule Book” for the Trail. Never has been. Never will be. There are over 7,000 folks who’ve done the whole Trail or most of it, and no two have done it exactly the same way.
There are folks who spend a lot of time criticizing how other people are doing the Trail—whether or not they slackpack, whether or not they spend too much time in towns, etc. In my experience, folks who spend much of their time carping about other folks’ trips are generally having pretty lousy ones of their own; people that are truly enjoying themselves don’t feel the need to spend time criticizing what other folks are doing.
Are there people who claim to have thru-hiked who actually haven’t? Sure there are. Lots of them. So what. That’s between them and their consciences; most folks don’t much care. I can understand some of Rick’s comments about folks who’ve yellow-blazed a lot of the Trail claiming to be thru-hikers, and I can understand some of his emotions about these folks. I know folks who’ve skipped Virginia yet claim to be thru-hikers. But these are extreme examples. And to criticize people who slackpack, or to malign a very brave man who’s attempting to thru-hike despite a very profound handicap seems excessive to me, and somewhat mean-spirited.
Rick: Most folks simply don’t care that much about what other folks are doing out there; most folks feel that it isn’t really anyone else’s business how someone else is hiking while out there.
And as for “rules” or “established rules” or “established traditions,” well, sorry Rick. These simply don’t exist, and for you to keep insisting that they do leaves you open to justified crtiticism: You are defending your arguments by citing rules and regulations that exist only in your mind; this isn’t helping your argument.
Baltimore Jack