Bleach h20 - Appalachian Trail

imported
#1

Regarding water treatment. Hiking the AT nobo in 05,(I am a spring drinker) I began using Polar Pure with a vitamin C aftertaste enhancer (at less than spring pure water) until I realized that the bottle says right on it that water has to be over 68 degrees F before iodine will kill giardia cysts. There is no 68 degree water on the AT and I wasn’t going to heat water whilst hiking. Switched to Aqua Mira (costly and seven minutes slow before one is able to resume walking.) Used some Katadyn brand chlorine tablets, no mixing, expensive, too. The worst water on the AT, from past experience began in Ct. and then Mass. north, with lots of beaver ponds and runoff streams, by then we began carrying a filter. (MSR Ceramic.) Of course I’m still drinking springs when they flow from the breast of Mother Nature (some in Pa. were sketchy.)Woodrose, my hiking partnerwife, who drinks about half of the water that I do, insisted on filtered water , she carried and cranked the filter. Realizing that AMira and Katadyn chlorine was chlorine in some form, way back south I had begun carrying a little vial of household bleach, and treated most of the water that I drank on the AT that wasn’t spring source with 5-6 drops in a big Nalgene bottle, waited 15 minutes and drank 'er down no problemas. Bleach little nicks and cuts, too. Trying to hike the PCT next year. Any bleach droppers out west ??? Muleskinner

Muleskinner

#2

Muleskinner: from what i’ve gathered, there are different types of chlorine. Some people have reported that the chlorine in house-hold bleach is not good for human consumption. If I were you I would do a bit of searching on the internet on this subject.

I am a “spring drinker” like you. On two PCT thru-hikes I simply carried a tiny bottle of “Potable Aqua” iodine tabs for emergency use. I never had a problem on either hike & ended up using less than one bottle of iodine on each trip.

There have been some very interesting articles on backcountry water quality in the past year or so. In one of the articles, a bunch of sources were tested in the Sierra’s of California (many of them near the PCT) and the findings were remarkable. (sources included springs, streams, and a couple rivers) The worst backcountry water source had better water quality than San Francisco City water!!!

Have a great hike & happy trails!

freebird

#3

Hey freebird! Do you have any links to the articles you mentioned? I’d love to see them! thanks!
Remy. :cheers

Remy

#4

‘Outside magizine’ did a water quality test, High Sierra vs. San Fran, in the summer of '03 or '04, should be easy to track down. Anyway, results were 10X the micro organism count in city water than in Sierra water. Also, the toxicity (non-organic) was greater for mecury, lead, and many other elements/compounds.

(yo, freebird. CDT next?)

hellkat

#5

hey Remy!

sorry, but no links - i saw the Outside Magazine article somewhere on the PCT in '05 (maybe the Saufley’s?) The other article was in a Backpacker Magazine that I saw @ the “secret shelter” in VT when i was on the Long Trail this summer. i dunno the exact issue.

Hellkat - nope, no CDT for me yet. 3 words kinda sum it up: I hate roadwalking :slight_smile: What are you up to?

cheers, freebird

freebird

#6

I think you all might be thinking about this link:

http://lomaprieta.sierraclub.org/pcs/articles/giardia.asp

Essentially this article says we’re over-reacting with a lot of talk about the dangers of Giardia in the water: “Proper personal hygiene is far more impor tant in avoiding giardiasis than treating the water”.

Brian Osborne

#7

Lord preserve an’ protect us we been drinkin’ chlorine for breakfus. Muleskinner:cheers :cheers

Muleskinner

#8

paparazzi sent me a link to one-thanks!

Remy