I can clearly see both sides of this arguement, If I saw somebody walking down the trail carrying on a conversation for no particular reason accept to be talking, I’d be less than happy with that individual. You can do that stuff at home. As for having it for protection, I agree with it giving you a false sense of security. What is somebody going to tell a rapist “hang on a second while I call 911”. Even if for some strange and unbelievable reason they did hold on, by the time help got there they wouldn’t be. Now on the other hand, medical emergencies are something in which Cell phones can and have saved lives. I am certainly not against anyone carrying a cell phone on the trail. People cary radio’s and nobody gets upset, people carry pocket mail and nobody gets upset, I’m carrying a GPS unit and a PDA and keyboard for research purposes and so far nobodies got upset. If they get upset because of towers, that’s nonsense, you could ban all phones from the trail and those towers would go up anyway. I guess what I’m saying is HYOH, but be mindful of others. If you feel the need to have a meaningless conversation don’t do it in the middle of a crowded shelter, because when your done you’ll probably get an earful. Lastly, with the current state of affairs this countries in, having an outside way of contact might not be a bad idea. Just my .02 worth.
BearKat