Need new tent suggestions

imported
#1

Greetings all,

After selling my Lunar solo recently (being 6’2 I couldn’t handle the constant rubbing against the seemingly perma-damp walls), I’m back in the market for a new tent. I’ve borrowed a buddy’s MSR Hubba and thought it was a pretty good tent, but I wanted to check with all you gear nerds here to see if there was anything else I should be paying attention too.

At this point I think I’m probably done with single-walled tents, unless theres just a totally awesome one that I don’t know about. I’ve looked into the Big Agnes Seedhouse, but have heard mixed reviews.

What say you gear Trailforumsers?

Rocham

#2

May I suggest my LightHeart Tent, at 1 lb 10 oz, it uses hiking poles to set it up, has about 42 inches of head room, plenty of length for a 6’2" guy and all his gear. (it’s actually about 11 feet tip to tip) it is a double wall tent in the shape of a diamond. It is not a free standing tent, and does have to be staked down. The fly is attached, so it goes up all in one.
You can see a picture of it here on White Blaze
http://whiteblaze.net/forum/vbg/showimage.php?i=32195&catid=511

$225.00 plus shipping. I do special orders in any color I can get the silnylon in. Special orders can take up to 4 weeks for delivery as I have to special order the fabric and then make the tent, and the cost is $250.00.

I will have a website up and running in about one week, it will be www.lightheartgear.com

HeartFire

#3

I have used Ste[henson Warmlite tents for years. I find them well made, light weigjt, and durable. They come in all sizes and either single or double wa;;. Check them out at www.warmlite.com. There are a number of optional features you may choose, such as side windows.

Bapa

#4

I just bought a Rainbow from Henry Shires. Its about 1.5 lbs lighter then my Hubba. It looks to be pretty roomy though we’ll have to see about condensation.

Jalan

#5

I’m 6’1", and have been using a SeedHouse 1 for about three years now. I love the weight, ease of set-up, and durability, not to mention that I stay dry! The only thing I don’t like about it is crawling through the door at one end. I’ve looked at the Kelty 1-person tent (can’t remember the name at the moment) that is basicly the same design shape, but has entry on the long side of the tent. Looks much easier to get gear and yourself in and out, and I’ve seen them for around $100. Not sure about the length, and it’s a little heavier.

All in all, I like the SeedHouse, and it’s been a good shelter for me in all conditions.

bugleboy

#6

I have the MSR Hubba and I am also finished with single wall tents. My experience was similar to the ones above. If the MSR Hubba is long enough for you, I would keep it. Everyone I have talked with about this tent gives outstanding reviews. I personally love mine and I have used it in lots of rain on the AT. I stay dry.

Margaret

#7

Someone explain this to me as I’m also in the market for a new tent. The vibe from this thread seems to be saying that tarp-tents will not keep you dry in prolonged rain (while 2-wall tents will). Correct me if I’m wrong, but it seems to me that if you get a tarp-tent long enough for your height (and so are not brushing up against the wall), that it’d be just as dry inside as a convential 2-wall tent (such as the Hubba or Seedhouse)… right? I mean, I can’t see how an inner-2nd-wall of mesh would keep water out. Though, I had heard that single-walled tents suffered from inside-misting during heavy rains, and so was wondering if an inner mesh-wall helps capture this mist???

psig

#8

While I did have significant condensation in a Six Moon Designs Lunar Solo (since sold), I’ve had very little in Henry Shires’ Tarptents. IMHO, Henry’s tents are generally better ventilated. I found that the long “skirts” of the Lunar Solo, while great for preventing splash, tended to gather moisture from the ground outside and funnel it into the tent. I have not had any trouble staying dry in prolonged rain, even in the Lunar Solo when I stayed away from the walls.

It is a good idea to follow the instructions for reducing condensation on the Tarptent web site. It’s also important to have enough room that you’re not rubbing the tent wall (at only 5’3", I had problems with this in the Lunar Solo, probably because of my 2.5" thick air pad). I’ve had lots more problems with condensation in a double-wall tent, in which severe condensation on the fly leaked through the inner wall. (Never get a tent with an outward-slanting screen door, which has to be closed up tight in the merest drizzle.) IMHO, ventilation, not the number of walls, is the key. I never had the “misting” problem that some report, even during a series of cloudbursts (every evening for three days, in addition to all-day lighter rain) in the Colorado Rockies. However, I suspect that heavy rain hitting a tent with condensation inside will jar some of it loose. It never hurts to bring something to wipe condensation off the tent walls if it does become significant (something you can’t do from inside in a double-wall tent).

I personally would never go back to a double-wall tent–I find them far too claustrophobic!

grannyhiker

#9

I would also consider the seedhouse 2 SL. it comes in at 3 lb 6 oz which is just a few oz more than the MSR Hubba but if gives you the versatility of using it as a small two person tent or a roomy one person tent. at 6 ft 2 in the Seedhouse 1 was too small for me IMO.
The new double wall tarp tent models look interesting but not much lighter than a Hubba or Seedhouse 2!
-Mat/LaundroMat

Mat MacDonald