Siltarp vs White Lightnin

imported
#1

Anyone care to share their experience pro or con with either the Integral Designs Siltarp 2 or the Granite Gear White Lightnin Tarp? I will be using them in the Cascades but don’t know which one to get…

noknees

#2

I bought the white lightnin and have used it once.

It pitches very easy with hiking poles or between trees. Takes 8 stakes with one and 6 the other.
It’s designed well for the “pup tent” look but doesn’t really work as well other ways. It’s sewn well and you can really get a tight pitch.

I wish I’d gotten the 10x10 instead of 8x10 for higher head room.

The biggest complaint I have is the color. The inside at night stayed bright and kept me awake.
I’m going to try dying it but the material probably won’t take.
Pete

pete56