Well, I can’t help but weigh in that that there are plenty of folks that hike with partners successfully. While many are in romantic relationships, I’ve seen some really functional pairs of friends, too. Plus, there are many partnerships or even small teams that form on trail and end up staying together for the duration. Sure, some teams fall apart, but many manage to stay friends/married/together, etc and come out stronger for the experience. There will always be occassional tense moments, but there would be anyway, even if you weren’t on trail.
Besides the gear-sharing advantages, there are many intangible benefits to sharing such a life-changing event with another person. That partner, of all the people you know before your hike, will be the only one who knows exactly what you went through, and can relate to how it has changed you. Family and non-hikers want to understand, or pretend to, but they usually just don’t get it. Your partner will.
There is also the reality that two heads really are better than one. Sometimes you just need another person to tell you when you’re not thinking clearly, and are about to make a bad decision. This can be especially important when conditions get dicey, or when hypothermia or heat stress enter the picture. On less developed trails, it can make route-finding easier, and stream-crossings safer.
Hiking with a partner means making compromises sometimes. You need patience and compassion if one of you is injured and the other is healthy, or if one of you is just having a tough day. Sometimes you need enough mental strength to carry the both of you along for a while. You need to find a pace that works for you both, and you need to learn to work together. And the single most important skill - you need to be able to laugh. A lot. You’ll want to anyway, so that’s the easy part.
I truly enjoy having my partner there to share the views, the joys, the pain. Two trails and counting, always walking together (!), and Jeff and I haven’t managed to kill each other yet! I won’t say the odd thought of the ol’ hiking pole to the head never crossed our minds, but we’re both still eager to hike together again, if that says anything.
Don’t categorically rule out hiking with a partner. It’s not for everyone, but when it works, it can add to your experience tremendously.
Chipper