Tarptent vs. Nomadlite

imported
#1

Alright, I am “only” a sectioner, but am planning to do the “northern section” from Harpers Ferry to Maine in a yr or two. I have primarily used shelters and at times have carried the only tent I own, a 2man 5lb. Light Wedge 2. I am in need of less shelter weight, and have stumbled upon the Henry Shire’s tarptent, and Kurt Russell’s nomadlite. Both seem similar in weight, ease of use, cost, and size. I would like to hear from anyone having experience with them to help me understand if condensation will be much of an issue, is either one a better choice, etc. I also recently changed from a synthetic bag to a western mountaineering down bag, will the dampness/condensation of the single wall shelter be of concern on the AT, etc.

Cutman11

#2

I use the Moonbow Gear tarp tent which is based on Henry Shires design and do not have much of a problem with condensation. My tent is low at the foot end and my sleeping bag will rub on the tent wall and gets wet but other then that no problems.

Big B

#3

Ultimately your real question may be which shelter can you actually get!?!

Kurt has a very very very long wait list ((i waited for almost 6 months without him answering a single email or phone call – and eventually gave up)), whereas Henry Shires kept me posted regarding my order ((even offered suggestions regarding a tarp setup question)).

I have only set up the tarptent in the backyard – but already notice a great amount of ventilation ((my version has the floor sewn in – with netting between the floor and walls)).

Amy (the good one)

#4

Aloha Cutman11! I have the Nomadlite and absolutely love it. It was well used on my AT hike.

Pros: very light weight, uses your poles (if you carry poles), easy set up; allows for sitting up in the center, fits approximately 1.5 people (me and my pack did just fine - pack against the side when raining or at the foot for leg lift), and has good ventilation depending on which model you get. Cons: pointed ends may cause problems for taller folks (I’m 5’10" and did fine with room for placing boots, etc if needed); footprint is much longer than most resulting in limiting campsites at times (particularly in the north); single-wall construction can cause more condensation than other choices due to being closer to the face (heavy breathers) or skin. I never really had much of a condensation problem but I’ve heard the opposite for a few (very few) others.

It’s my understanding from others purchasing from Kurt this past year or so that he’s quite behind schedule and hard to reach. (A little slower than anticipateded in '01, received one week prior to starting, but he did throw in Sil stuff sacks of various sizes as an apology.) Should you decide to go this route, you may consider looking online (this site and others) for used Nomads being sold. I was just chatting with a seller about his priced at $285 - never used. I believe Hammockhanger also just purchased a used one for something like $175. There are different models resulting in different airflows (better ventilation windows) so keep an eye out for that also. Anyway, they’re out there – maybe an email on a couple of gear selling lists will do the trick.

Good luck on your search. Ain’t gear shopping fun!

Aloha!

In short, I really do love my Nomad and anticipate taking it on my PCT hike next year.

Aloha! Ann

#5

Hi there, I looked at both of these tents and decided on the Six Moon Designs tent instead. They have them in stock. It only weights 33oz. Single wall. Not much condensation. Plenty of room for one and back pack. 2 men would fit. I have only used once on an overnight trip so far. I have seen both of the others in person because friends have them. I like this much better. Good price at $250.00. I also got the vestibule for mine. I love my new tent!
Hikerman.

Hikerman