Dear baganoosh, Tucson and Captn:
There are several reasons why one can lose upper body mass (or seem to) during a through hike.
First, during a through hike (or even during the walking program I described above), assuming a proper diet, you will be losing fat from all areas of your body, wherever it is stored. This includes the upper body and arms.
Second, during a through hike, you will gaining muscle in your legs (again assuming a proper diet) due to the tremendous amount of work they do. Moreso in the calves, but also in the thighs and buttocks.
But, in walkihng or hikihng, your upper body simply does not do the same amount of work as your lower body, and so does not build muscle to the same degree. Your stabilizing muscles get plenty of endurance work, like your abdominals, lower back, and so forth,your trunk basically, but it is more endurance work than strength building work. So, with respect to your upper body, your trunk muscles should gain an increased endurance capacity, but not necessarily get larger as you are not working your upper body with increasing amounts of weight. In fact, if you were lifting weights prior to hiking/walking, and then don’t lift weights while you are primarily hiking/walking, your upper body muscles should atrophy from a strenghth point of view, because you’re simply not lifing weights any more, not giving them the same amount of work. Meanwhile, your legs are carrying more weight (your pack), working all day, doing endless squats and toe raises. For the same thing to happen to your upper body, you’d have to lift weights or swim harder and harder each day for a time equal to the duration of your through-hike.
And finally…
Third, depending on your body composition (% of lean mass versus % of fat), a person can have much more fat stored in an apparently trim upper body than one might expect. This is because muscles themselves can store fat, and it is only when the muscles’ capacity to store fat is reached, that the body begins to store fat between the muscles and the outer layers of skin. This is why, for example, as people age and become more sedentary, they can, for a period of time, appear to be unchanged, while in fact their body composition is changing. That is, they appear unchanged, while in fact their muscles are atrophying, because the muscles are storing fat intramuscularly and thus appear to be the same size. But, everyone who has weight-trained at some point in his or her life, realizes the difference between “hard” muscle and “soft muscle”, the difference being of course that the “hard muscle” has little or no fat, while the “soft muscle” is maximizing its capacity to store fat and has in effect become a storage area for fat. The point here, is that even a person who appears to be slim, can have a high percentage of fat in his or her overall body weight (men should be no more than 15% fat, women no more than 24% fat). As such, the fat loss could appear to be muscle atrophy, when in fact much of the appearance of atrophy could in fact be the loss of substantial amounts of intramuscular fat.
To the person who now screams: “But my upper body got weaker!” I can only suggest to you that by changing the way you used your upper body during your through hike, you must have somehow acted in a manner that demanded less strength from your upper body. That’s the most likely explaination, as muscles grow or decrease in size based on one principle, the SAID principle, which means: Specific Adaptions to Imposed Demands. If you lift heavier weights regularly, you will increase the size of the muscle; if you lift less, or not at all, you muscle will decrease in size. If you begin doing more repetitions of a movement, your body will create new (more) blood vessels in the relevant muscles to allow for increased aerobic activity in the form of more repetitions. If you become inactive, over time, some of those new blood vessels will disappear.
With regards to diet, a quick word. You’ve got to have sufficient carbs to burn for fuel, along with your body fat, and sufficient protein to rebuild your muscles which are being torn down every day under your massive hiking workload. If you cheat yourself on carbohydrates, your body will use your dietary protein for fuel, with the result that your dietary protein won’t be available for muscle and tissue repair. If you get plenty of calories, but not enough dietary protein, you’ll develop the same problem. So, careful attention must be paid to what you are eating and what nutrients are contained therein. Basically, you want nutrient dense foods, not empty calorie foods. If you constantly work, work, work your body, as through hiking does, and you fail to consume the nutrients (including protein) to repair and rebuild your bodily parts, they will all eventually break down. You want to do all you can to avoid that. You want to stenghten, cruise comfortably, and glide into infinity.
Sorry to go on so long.
Sincerely–Conan.
Conan